Our Cerebral Palsy Surgery – SPML & Alcohol Block

Well, we just got back from a trip to Texas to see Dr. Yngve at UTMB. These pics are from right after Everett got out of the hospital (the same day as the surgery) and let me tell you the first 24 hours were rough! Everett really struggled to wake up from the anesthesia and he was just cranky about everything! He had to wear those immobilizers for the first 24 hours and that was really hard because the slightest jostle would set him off screaming. Now, we only have to put on the immobilizers when he’s sleeping, so when he’s awake he only has to wear the little casts (below the knee). P1040476

Once we got him back to my cousin’s house, we sat him up in the stroller with a pillow propped under his legs but he wasn’t loving it.

P1040477

He has to keep the casts (and the immobilizers when sleeping) on for four weeks, at which time he’ll be fitted for AFO’s. We got the surgery to reduce spasticity in Everett’s legs and hips – mostly because his hip was starting to dislocate. This surgery is only a teensy bit invasive when compared to what he would need if his hip did actually dislocate. It’s also a lot less invasive that the standard tendon-lengthening procedure performed for kids with CP.

Everett will need to send a hip x-ray to Dr. Yngve every year until he turns 18, to monitor the hip and make sure it isn’t starting to dislocate again. The issue is that Everett isn’t standing, so his hip socket isn’t being formed correctly. The conventional approach is to put kids like Everett into a stander to help with this, but according to ABM practitioners and our own intuition he should be crawling before we put him into an artificial and forced standing posture. We don’t want him to learn to stand with force (by tensing up his muscles), because this just increases spasticity.

I’m going to put all the information we gathered about the surgery here, in case some other families are trying to learn more about the surgery.

First of all, let me say that this surgery is extremely confusing! If you try to discuss this with any other doctors, they will think that they know what you are talking about but they probably don’t! First, it goes by the same name (SPML/Selective Percutaneous Myofascial Lengthening/Percutaneous Lengthening) as the conventional tendon-lengthening surgery (which is more invasive and actually creates worse outcomes because it forms scar tissue that ends up being tighter than the original tendon). Second, “alcohol” is very confusing because PM&R docs or neurologists use phenol (the alcoholic chemical), but Drs. Yngve and Nuzzo use ethyl alcohol, which is NOT THE SAME.

It seems that Dr. Nuzzo in NJ pioneered the surgery and he has a LOT of information about it on his website. The surgery has two parts: alcohol block and SPML. Dr. Nuzzo’s website has a page that describes the alcohol block procedure HERE.

Here is Dr. Nuzzo’s description of the alcohol block procedure:

What has alcohol got to do with internuncials? Nothing directly. But indirectly, much. Alcohol (booze, ethyl, not talking about the alcoholic chemical called phenol), when injected right on a myelinated nerve strips the fat away. It creates a bald spot in the myelin. Myelinated nerves transmit impulses much faster than unmyelinated nerves. But the bald spot acts like a speed bump in the nerve. Fast trains of impulses pile up.

Dr. Nuzzo explains, “When a muscle gets hit with a single “go”, it responds. When it gets hit with a barrage of “gogogogogogogogogogogo,” it gets thrown into tetany, a rigid, hard-to-undo contractile state. Worse, it screams for help over feedback circuits which (in spasticity) are mistakenly linked into the motor circuits by reflex spinal pathways.”

More from his site:

So when a fast train of stimuli from receptors hits the speed bump [the defatted myelin around the nerve], the internuncials don’t receive “mommymommymommymommymommy” but more like “ahem, mother…………………. if I may, mother………….”. Thus the internuncials don’t get the rapid fire background stimulus that pushes them over the edge into stimulating their neighbors and every other nerve on the block. But alcohol, used in too large a volume can cause a burning sensation if it gets to mixed nerves. You need to have the capability of exactly placing a needle directly on the target nerve so as to inject a small volume of alcohol that won’t spread too far. For that, you need special needles  attached to special electronic ‘nerve finder” circuitry. The sparky needle procedure isn’t comfortable, so, it is usually done under anesthesia. Alcohol blocks last from six months to three years. It isn’t the alcohol that “lasts,” but the repair rate of the child in fixing the speed bump caused by the alcohol. Often there is some residual long effect.

So, let’s discuss this alcohol block procedure versus Botox, the conventional treatment for spasticity in kids with CP. Typically a neurologist would administer the Botox and the child is awake (no general anesthesia is definitely a perk), with the effects wearing off in about six months. According to Dr. Nuzzo, “Advantages over Botox include low toxicity and long duration of effect to many muscles at one time. A single inject [alcohol block] may well last 18 months to two years and not require repetition.” The main benefit in my eyes is that the alcohol block helps the brain deal with spasticity; whereas Botox is neurologically confusing since the nerve/muscles disappear after the Botox is injected then start to gradually reappear. Botox can give range of motion, but I am more interested in FUNCTION than simply range of motion!! The information the brain gets from Botox doesn’t seem like it would help the brain figure anything out. I am not at all an expert, but I think that Baclofen works the same way as Botox.

Everett had the surgery less than one week ago and already his right arm, shoulder, and hand are significantly looser. So, even though his surgery didn’t touch his arm/shoulder/hand, his brain is already figuring out how to communicate with his right arm, shoulder, and hand better!!!

On Monday, just three days after the surgery, here is Everett bearing weight on a open right hand FOR THE FIRST TIME!!! He is wearing a Bamboo Brace, but it’s soft (or, in industry lingo: dynamic!).

IMG_0946

And here he is, STANDING (bearing weight through his hips and legs, albeit leaning on the table) – FOR THE FIRST TIME EVER:

IMG_0942

So, in addition to the alcohol block, the procedure includes SPML, which is for tendon-lengthening. See Dr. Nuzzo’s explanation page HERE. The main difference between this SPML and the conventional procedure done by most orthopedic surgeons is that instead of cutting the tendon (which produces scar tissue and leads to LESS range of motion) they leave the muscle tendon alone and just cut tiny snips into the myofascia over the muscle surface (similar to mesh skin grafting).

From Dr. Nuzzo’s website:

Selective percutaneous myofascia lengthening now seldom divides even 10% of the fascia in the limited subset of muscles selected in virgin cases. However, surgery is more extensive when scar from old standard open procedures complicates recurrent contracture. Scar from those old lengthenings is far more resistant to lengthening than the muscle contracture itself. We think that is why standard lengthenings have a much higher recurrence rate. It is the scar itself.

Another phenomenon caught our notice. There were children who had a certain degree of spasticity and difficulty walking and who were treated with standard lengthenings and who did well initially. With time, recurrence did not just lose that advantage. Certain of the children seemed to become worse than they were before their old surgery, even at less or similar degrees of contracture – worse neurologically. They seemed more spastic, more reactive, more sensitive to velocity.

Dr. Nuzzo also has a FAQ page HERE

So, if Dr. Nuzzo pioneered this procedure and has all this great info on his website, why did we go to Texas to see Dr. Yngve? Well, Dr. Nuzzo trained Dr. Yngve, so we figured he’s pretty good. =) But the main reason is that Dr. Yngve accepts the ridiculously low amount that our insurance is willing to pay! We would have had to pay between $6K and $8K out of pocket if we had gone to New Jersey. We paid $0 to see Dr. Yngve!

Again, I am posting this info because when we were seeing Everett curve his body like a C and his hips were starting to dislocate, I found it very difficult to find straight answers on all this and I was extremely frustrated talking to local doctors while trying to get the referral from my insurance company. A neurologist told me that using alcohol (he thought I was talking about phenol) was outdated and archaic. An orthopedic surgeon told me that he has done the exact same procedure on hundreds of kids with CP (but only Dr Nuzzo and Dr Yngve do this procedure based on my research). Another orthopedic surgeon told me that Everett’s hips weren’t that bad and he didn’t need any surgery at all. I guess it was a risk I was willing to take since it’s so non-invasive when compared to the surgery we would need if his hips did dislocate.

If your child has had any of the treatments discussed in this post, please leave a comment and share how it went.

About these ads

23 thoughts on “Our Cerebral Palsy Surgery – SPML & Alcohol Block

  1. Nicole,
    My name is Brittany, I also have Cerebral Palsy. I was born with it as a result of being premature. My Mother had an emergency C-section at 26 weeks. I was 2lbs exactly. I am 24 years old, I am married and have 3 children. Everett’s story touched me.. I just wanted to say, my Mom was my greatest supporter, and she still is. As long as Everett has the support of his family he will go far! Never ever ever give up on him! What a great testimony he is, Praise God :)

  2. Sis, these pics brought tears to my eyes!!! Everett is doing so good what a strong boy!!! So proud of him!

  3. Pingback: Everett Therapy Update May 2013 | The Pantry Book

  4. My daughter Claire had a stroke 2 weeks before she was born. She is a right hemi. I am a pediatric OT from Knoxville and happened to work with a former patient of Dr Yngve. This year I have referred 2 other patients to him as a miracle doctor! The result was AMAZING!!!!!! Soooooo this time next week my daughter and I will be in Galveston! I have one question… Does he not work on the blow or hand if it is interacting? I know it will help her toe walking but what about her elbow? Do you know? Thanks and God Bless

    • Hi Michelle,
      Thanks for commenting! I think that Dr. Yngve only does hips/knees/ankles – but you should definitely ask him. I do know that Everett’s right hand, elbow, and shoulder are much more open since the surgery. And by open, I mean we have improved range of motion AND function!!! I agree, the surgery is a miracle! We will pray for you and your daughter next week. Let me know how it goes!

  5. We just had the SPML on my daughter’s elbow yesterday September 11 2013 we also
    Had the SPML on her hamstrings and also did the alcohol block I am super excited to see the results… I would like to know what other improvements have you seen since May?

    • I wish I could say that Everett has dramatically improved motorically this summer, but our progress has been really slow. We also spent two weeks in intensive ABM therapy in California and we still aren’t sitting, crawling or walking. But, Everett’s communication is like night and day. Now Everett can answer a question in the affirmative by saying “yeah” – which makes a HUGE difference. He also shakes his head for no and has a bunch of new sounds. His vision is a lot better and he has had almost no vision therapy this summer! All I can say is that the brain heals in the order that it wants to.

  6. Hi Nicole
    Not sure that this surgery is right for us but I wondered in your expertise if you think this doctor in Texas is the right doctor to do hip reconstruct or better yet I guess it would be more like making the socket reconstruction. The ball of the leg is dislocated at present and will not go in till the socket is reconstructed.

  7. Nicole,
    thanks for sahring it to the world. I live in Argentina and I have a 3 years old girl with CP, I was investigating about dr. Nuzzo’s surgery and found your post. do you mind telling me the cost of the proceedure? regards.

  8. Pingback: Spasticity and the Impact of SPML and SDR surgery on learning | Brain Plasticity through Neuro Movement Specialist - Anat Baniel Method Practitioner, Feldenkrais Method, Reflex - Holistic therapy to improve movement

  9. Hi Nicole, thank you so much, this blog explains SPML surgery very well. I was wondering if you could give us an update on how Everett is doing? You said he didn’t make as much progress as you’d hoped over the summer, but how was his last hip x-ray? Is it helping his hip joints form properly? Because that’s a big deal! How is he doing 18 months out from surgery? My daughter’s latest hip x-ray shows beginning signs of subluxation so we are now considering the surgery for our daughter (who’s also not sitting, crawling or walking) and are considering whether to do it now or wait until she’s older and moving more.

    • It’s hard to give a progress report because Everett’s improvement has been slow, but he has definitely improved and hasn’t gotten any worse. Everett still only army crawls (not up on hands and knees yet). But he also sits up and that helps A LOT. He can sit in the shopping cart at the grocery store and that is a game changer for me. Also, being stable in sitting means he can work on standing in therapy and that’s been really fun to see. I am familiar with the ABM “philosophy” against walkers, botox, etc., but I have also read some viewpoints that stress that there are times when therapy is unable to help because of the spasticity. I think that’s where this surgery is helpful. It seems like this particular surgery is ABM-approved, since all the kids we know from therapy have had it.

  10. Hi. We are on day 2 post spml and the larger slob hip surgery that dr Nuzzo does. Still too early to see results but I can warn that the recovery is brutal!!

    • My daughter Claire have SPML with Dr. Yngve June of 2013…… She was 4 and the closest her right heel could get to the ground was 3 1/2 inches. The first two weeks were brutal with the inmobilizers. BUT… Within two weeks, and since I am an OT and all my friends are therapists!, she was walking in her casts and flowed straight into a DAFO he ordered.

      Today… 2 years later…. THE BEST DECISION I EVER MADE. Beautiful gait and feet flat on the ground in a low DAFO!

      TRUST THE BEST- DR. YNGVE!!!!

      • She was back to walking in casts within 2 weeks. Then he had us step down into two sets of DAFO’s. But the minute her leg came out of the cast her heel was down and has been on the ground ever since. We sent Dr. Y before pictures from his office and a year later and it is AMAZING. Her right leg muscle is almost the exact as left and high tone is GONE. If only we could do the same for her arm!!! Just doesn’t work the same….

  11. Nicole,
    My son Matthew is 2 days post-op. Matthew was diagnosed with an inuter stroke when he was 2 and has right hemi. He is now 7 years old and since his diagnosis has undergone PT, OT, Botox, and wearing AFOs. I am hopeful to witness Matthew’s results. Thank you for your story.

  12. So glad to find your BLOG! You explain things so clearly. My son, 13, had SPML with Dr. Nuzzo in July ’13. His gait is much more aligned and “normal” looking. He uses a walker. I am very happy with the results and so are his neurologists and orthopedic surgeons. His PTs are very pleased as well. Dr. Nuzzo is an amazing human being. I have to say, though, that recovery was no “brutal” for us. He couldn’t walk for weeks, but my son took it all in stride. The hardest part was getting him on the toilet!

  13. Thank you so much for posting your experience. I am half way through my ABM basic training to become a practitioner and I have a 3 1/2 yo son with CP. We were advised that Grey would benefit from at least a block and maybe SPML. I don’t know much at all about it but am excited to hear your experience. Since you are now two years post surgery, can you see anything you wish you would have known beforehand or done differently?

    • Hi Erin,
      Most kids don’t need to repeat the surgery, but I think we will. I wish we had done Everett’s arm/shoulder, but I don’t think he needed it two years ago. No biggie since we’ll probably add it in when we go back to repeat the surgery. We are extremely happy with the results, but as they grow, spasticity can really increase quickly. Everett has really had a growth spurt so I think that’s the main reason he’s still so tight.
      He gets a lot of ABM and he’s been to two MNRI conferences since his surgery. It’s really hard to keep ahead of the spasticity. We just do our best.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s